RedStone "False Advertising"? Anger Erupts as Only 4,000 out of 230,000 Community Members Receive Airdrop
Original Title: "Only 4000 Qualified Addresses, Has RedStone's Airdrop Angered the Masses?"
Original Author: Alex Liu, Foresight News
On the evening of March 5th, RedStone initiated its airdrop query. Since its pre-market listing on Binance on February 28th, RED has hit Binance's latest circuit breaker for 3 consecutive days, breaking above $1.40 after the price limit was removed, and is now trading at $0.87 with a market cap of $34 million and a fully diluted market cap of $860 million.
As the latest Launchpad project on Binance, RedStone saw significant participation in its airdrop event, garnering attention in the community. Known for its low-cost reputation as a price oracle provider, the project has not experienced any major pricing errors since its launch and has received support from notable investment firms such as Coinbase Ventures and Blockchain Capital. However, this shining star's reputation took a nosedive in the community after the launch of the airdrop query page last night, with some netizens even labeling it a "scam project." But why?

Looking at its tokenomics, a 10% community airdrop allocation is not considered low and does not seem to be the root of the issue. On social media platforms, community members have provided feedback that they participated in multi-year tasks (such as mining activities in Seasons 1-3, over a hundred tasks on Zealy, Lunar New Year events, etc.) but still did not receive the airdrop. In RedStone's official statement, the author found the answer.

Only those with specific roles in the RedStone Discord are eligible to receive tokens! Qualified roles include Vein Master, Deep Miner, Professor, IRL (participated in offline events), etc., and the proportion of RedStone Discord's nearly 230,000 community members with any of these roles is less than 2%!
Merely offering a small amount of tokens may not have angered community users to this extent (RedStone DC has now activated "slow mode" due to excessive criticism), but the actual reward mechanism being inconsistent with the project's promotion has led many users to feel that their efforts were in vain, which is likely the crux of the issue.

In past promotions, the project team exclaimed, "Your points will be the key basis for future airdrops!" However, in reality, the top 10 holders in the RSG Points ranking, including the 5th and 7th places, were disqualified from receiving RED tokens because they did not have a Discord role. Out of more than 170,000 people on the leaderboard, only 2296 addresses were eligible. With around 200,000 members in the entire community, only about four thousand people ultimately met the airdrop criteria, with many users receiving only a few hundred tokens. The distribution logic appeared to be very "selective" compared to other mainstream projects in the market.

Data Source: @OshinoAJ_eth
So what truly sparked the anger of community members is that RedStone's event design was full of intense "PUA" style marketing: by continuously releasing tasks to attract user participation, it created an illusion of "as long as you are diligent enough, you can receive rewards." In reality, there were invisible barriers in the threshold setting, causing many ordinary users who invested a significant amount of time and resources to be excluded at the last moment.
This goes against industry norms. Other airdrop projects in the industry usually focus more on the broad participation of users in the distribution mechanism. In dYdX's airdrop event, tens of thousands of participating and eligible users generally receive a certain amount of governance tokens; and in projects like Optimism, their airdrop rules are clear, fair, and transparent, aiming to encompass a larger number of ecosystem users.
In contrast, RedStone's "special role" threshold appears too narrow, making it difficult to incentivize long-term community activity and trust.
Conclusion
The project team may have attempted to achieve a more sophisticated incentive mechanism in airdrop distribution, ensuring that core users receive a higher percentage of rewards. However, this approach undoubtedly overlooks the contributions and expectations of the broader participants.
In the long run, airdrops are not only a means to attract users as a promotional tool but also a crucial indicator of project governance transparency and ecosystem health. The current controversy undoubtedly sounds an alarm for the entire industry: only by establishing a fair, open, and reasonable incentive distribution mechanism can users truly feel the value of participation and thus drive the continuous prosperity of the entire ecosystem.
You may also like

What Happened in Crypto Today? Solana-Native Rails Launch on Digitap ($TAP) as the Best Crypto to Buy
Key Takeaways Digitap ($TAP) spearheads the transition toward real-world utility in cryptocurrency, offering a seamless financial ecosystem through…

Here’s Why Fed Contender Kevin Warsh is Seen as Bearish for Bitcoin
Key Takeaways Kevin Warsh is a potential nominee for the U.S. Federal Reserve chair, causing concerns due to…

XRP Breaks Below Its 1-Year Support Range: What’s Next?
Key Takeaways XRP has slipped below its critical support range of $1.8 to $2.1, which had been steadfast…

XRP Price Breakdown Intensifies — Can Support Mitigate the Shock?
Key Takeaways XRP has dipped below the significant $1.80 mark, continuing its downtrend. The asset is trading beneath…

XRP Risk-Adjusted Returns Suggest a Period of Consolidation – Insights and Analysis
Key Takeaways: XRP’s recent price fluctuations highlight a lack of strong market momentum for a trend reversal. The…

Kevin Warsh Associated with Crypto Project Basis and Electric Capital
Key Takeaways Kevin Warsh, former U.S. Federal Reserve Board Governor, is associated with crypto initiatives Basis and Electric…

Why is Trump’s Fed Chair Pick Kevin Warsh Seen as Bad News for Precious Metals, Commodities, Bitcoin, and Equities?
Key Takeaways: Kevin Warsh, once appointed, is expected to take a more hawkish stance on monetary policy, which…

Who Is Kevin Warsh? How His Fed Chair Odds Are Influencing Bitcoin Markets
Key Takeaways Kevin Warsh, a former Federal Reserve governor, is becoming a strong candidate for the next Fed…

Strategy (MSTR) Stock: Michael Saylor’s Bitcoin Bet Goes Red But Here’s The Twist
Key Takeaways Strategy’s Bitcoin investment has dipped below its average purchase price, highlighting market volatility. No immediate financial…

Gov-Backed Asset or Solana Meme? Uncovering the Reality Behind the USOR Crypto Frenzy
Key Takeaways USOR, a Solana token, sparked a debate over its legitimacy by claiming associations with U.S. strategic…

Bitcoin Hashrate Falls 12% After US Winter Storms Hit Miners
Key Takeaways: The total network hashrate for Bitcoin has declined by approximately 12% since November 11, marking the…

Gold’s Six-Month Rally Against Bitcoin Shows Parallels to 2019 Cycle
Key Takeaways Gold has consistently outperformed bitcoin over the last six months, despite being typically considered the haven…

Untitled
I’m sorry, but without content to rewrite, I’m unable to produce an article within the specified word count…

Mantle’s Cross-Chain Era on Solana: Onboarding the Bybit Express to Mantle Super Portal
Key Takeaways Bybit joins forces with Mantle to enhance cross-chain asset flows through the Mantle Super Portal. Mantle…

XRP Price Outlook for 2026: Is Bitcoin Hyper Part of Long Term Themes?
Key Takeaways The potential future of XRP in 2026 is significant, with various factors influencing its growth and…

Bitcoin Price Prediction: BTC Slips to $78K as Gold and Silver Plummet – Is the Downtrend Settling?
Key Takeaways Bitcoin and traditional safe havens like gold and silver experience synchronized declines in a volatile market…

$30 Million Heist: Step Finance Treasury Wallets Breached
Key Takeaways Step Finance, a prominent Solana-based DeFi platform, faced a significant security breach, losing approximately $30 million…

Bitcoin Price Prediction: $50B Volume Drops 40% as BTC Tests $83K – Is a Breakdown Next?
Key Takeaways: Bitcoin’s trading volume has seen a significant decline, indicating cautious trader behavior. Bitcoin prices remain under…
What Happened in Crypto Today? Solana-Native Rails Launch on Digitap ($TAP) as the Best Crypto to Buy
Key Takeaways Digitap ($TAP) spearheads the transition toward real-world utility in cryptocurrency, offering a seamless financial ecosystem through…
Here’s Why Fed Contender Kevin Warsh is Seen as Bearish for Bitcoin
Key Takeaways Kevin Warsh is a potential nominee for the U.S. Federal Reserve chair, causing concerns due to…
XRP Breaks Below Its 1-Year Support Range: What’s Next?
Key Takeaways XRP has slipped below its critical support range of $1.8 to $2.1, which had been steadfast…
XRP Price Breakdown Intensifies — Can Support Mitigate the Shock?
Key Takeaways XRP has dipped below the significant $1.80 mark, continuing its downtrend. The asset is trading beneath…
XRP Risk-Adjusted Returns Suggest a Period of Consolidation – Insights and Analysis
Key Takeaways: XRP’s recent price fluctuations highlight a lack of strong market momentum for a trend reversal. The…
Kevin Warsh Associated with Crypto Project Basis and Electric Capital
Key Takeaways Kevin Warsh, former U.S. Federal Reserve Board Governor, is associated with crypto initiatives Basis and Electric…